Fayetteville, AR vs Springfield, MO: Housing and Utility Costs in 2026
Springfield is the cheaper place to live, with three-bedroom rent $283 a month below Fayetteville’s and a median home value $171,900 lower. Utilities barely separate them: the average monthly electric bill is $129.13 in Arkansas and $129.18 in Missouri, a five-cent difference at the state level.
Housing therefore decides this comparison, and the size of the home you need matters most. A one-bedroom renter saves only $60 a month in Springfield. For how both cities rank nationally, see our cost comparison of 23 mid-size cities.
Fayetteville vs Springfield: Quick Cost Comparison
| Metric | Fayetteville, AR | Springfield, MO | Winner / Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1BR median gross rent | $867 | $807 | Springfield by $60/mo |
| 3BR median gross rent | $1,508 | $1,225 | Springfield by $283/mo |
| Top state income tax rate | 3.70% | 4.70% | Fayetteville by 1 pt |
| Effective property tax (implied) | 0.56% | 0.75% | Fayetteville |
| Estimated tax on a $300,000 primary home | $2,838 | $2,840 | Near tie |
| Median home value | $349,600 | $177,700 | Springfield by $171,900 |
| Avg. monthly electric (state) | $129.13 | $129.18 | Arkansas by $0.05 |
| Avg. monthly internet | No official city figure | No official city figure | Compare by address |
| Base combined sales tax | 9.75% | 8.10% | Springfield by 1.65 pts |
| Mean commute | 18.5 min | 17.6 min | Springfield by 0.9 min |
| Median household income | $62,695 | $49,311 | Fayetteville by $13,384 |
Housing, income, and commute figures are from the Census Bureau’s 2020–2024 American Community Survey. Gross rent includes tenant-paid utilities. Electric bills are 2024 statewide averages from the EIA.
Rent: The Gap Depends on Bedrooms
These two college-town markets look almost alike at one bedroom. Springfield’s $807 median is only $60 below Fayetteville’s $867, a saving of $720 a year. At three bedrooms the difference grows to $283 a month, or $3,396 a year, because Fayetteville’s family-size rentals cost far more than its small apartments.
The table below shows what a median three-bedroom rental takes from a gross salary in each city.
| Gross salary | Fayetteville 3BR share | Springfield 3BR share | Annual rent difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| $75,000 | 24.1% | 19.6% | $3,396 |
| $110,000 | 16.5% | 13.4% | $3,396 |
Because gross rent already includes tenant-paid utilities, do not add a full electric bill to these figures. They are medians for existing tenants, so current listings near either university or downtown can run higher. Renters comparing other Plains and Ozarks options can use our Wichita and Tulsa rent comparison.
Buying a Home: Where the Cities Really Split
The median Fayetteville home is worth nearly twice the median Springfield home, $349,600 against $177,700. On a 10% down payment, that difference means about $17,190 more cash at closing in Fayetteville, followed by a much larger mortgage for as long as you own the house.
Fayetteville’s higher household income explains part of the premium, at $62,695 compared with $49,311 in Springfield. A remote worker paid from elsewhere can benefit most from the Springfield side of that equation, since their salary does not depend on local wages. Our Bentonville and Tulsa comparison for remote workers shows the same pattern elsewhere in the region.
Property Tax: Two Systems, One Surprising Result
Arkansas assesses property at 20% of market value. The state’s 2026 millage table lists 57.3 mills for a Fayetteville address in the Fayetteville School District. A $300,000 home has $60,000 of assessed value and a gross bill of $3,438, and the homestead credit of up to $600 brings it to about $2,838.
Missouri assesses residential property at 19%. Greene County’s levy table gives a 2025 total of about $4.982 per $100 for a home inside Springfield and the Springfield R-12 district with no fire district. The same $300,000 home has $57,000 of assessed value and owes about $2,840, within a few dollars of the Fayetteville estimate.
The real difference comes from price. At each city’s median value, the estimate is about $3,406 in Fayetteville and $1,682 in Springfield, so the typical Springfield buyer pays roughly $1,724 less each year. Census medians show a smaller gap, $1,946 against $1,326, because they include longtime owners and older valuations. Levies change by district, so confirm the rate for a specific parcel.
Utilities: Why the State Average Is Only a Start
The EIA’s 2024 residential table puts Arkansas and Missouri within a nickel of each other, which makes electricity close to a tie at the state level. A city’s actual bill depends on its provider, the size and age of the house, and whether it heats with gas or electricity.
That matters most when you compare a newer apartment with an older single-family home. Before signing, ask the landlord or seller for 12 months of electric, gas, and water bills. A year of real statements captures both summer cooling and winter heating, which a single month cannot do. Internet deserves the same address-level check, because no federal agency publishes an average bill by city.
Income and Sales Tax
Arkansas has the lower top income tax rate, at 3.70% for 2026, compared with Missouri’s 4.70%. As a screening rule, one percentage point on $60,000 of taxable income is about $600 a year. That can offset most of a one-bedroom renter’s $720 saving in Springfield, but only a small part of the $3,396 three-bedroom saving. Deductions differ between the states, so run your own return before relying on that estimate.
Sales tax moves in the other direction. Fayetteville’s combined rate is 9.75%, while Springfield’s base rate is 8.1%. Some Springfield shopping districts charge more, so the gap can narrow depending on where you buy.
Which City Should You Choose?
Choose Springfield if you need three bedrooms, plan to buy, or want the lowest total housing cost. Choose Fayetteville if you want a one-bedroom and value a lower state income tax, since the two costs nearly cancel for a single renter. Anyone considering a longer move west can compare another pair of housing markets in our Boise and Spokane cost breakdown.
More city comparisons: Huntsville vs Chattanooga cost of living, Chattanooga vs Knoxville property taxes, and Carmel vs Fishers cost of living.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Fayetteville or Springfield cheaper to live in?
Springfield is cheaper for most households. Its three-bedroom rent is $283 a month lower and its median home value is $171,900 lower. The one-bedroom gap is just $60 a month, so a single renter may find that Arkansas’s lower income tax rate makes the two cities nearly even.
Are utilities cheaper in Fayetteville or Springfield?
State averages are almost identical, at $129.13 a month in Arkansas and $129.18 in Missouri. Those figures cannot show the difference between local providers or individual homes. Ask for 12 months of billing history on any address you are considering, because insulation, heating fuel, and home size can matter more.
How much is property tax on a $300,000 home in each city?
A $300,000 primary home owes about $2,838 in Fayetteville after the $600 homestead credit and about $2,840 inside Springfield and its R-12 school district. The result is nearly a tie at equal prices, but Springfield homes usually cost far less, so its typical annual bill is lower.
This article is for general information only and is not financial, tax, legal, or real estate advice. Tax estimates are simplified and rates vary by address and household. Confirm current figures with the relevant agency or a licensed professional before making a decision.


